In this section I present a series of cases studies that explore different portable antenna configurations. This list is an initial start, and I plan to add aditional studies over time. A link is provided to the articles.
In all cases my 'reference' antenna for the studies is the Chameleon MPAS Lite antenna system; a broadband non-resonant ground mounted vertical antenna with ground radials. I choose this antenna system because it produces an omni-directional antenna pattern and it allows for directional gains in the 'test' antennas to be observed in the results. It is also simple to deploy and requires no adjustments to the antenna system when changing bands as long as you use an antenna tuner.
I have the privledge of collaborating with Tim (K5OHY) who shares a similar passion for antenna analysis and antenna comparisons using real-world data. Tim has a web based software tool called the FarField Lab. The software uses RBN and WSPR to analyze and assess your antenna reach, and allow for antenna performance comparisions. He has implemented in his software the methodology outlined in this work for calculating the relative gain between two antennas. Give it a try!
Case Studies
Whip Antenna Comparison Study - With the advent of portable and handheld QRP transceivers a short whip antenna has become popular. This study looks at the relative gain of a 45" whip antenna (found on the Elecraft KH1 and the AX1 antenna).
EFRW Antenna Study - For ultimate portability a simple end-fed random wire antenna is perfectly suited for SOTA operations. This study looks at the relative gain of the Tufteln 4:1 EFRW antenna.
Vertical + Sloper Wire Study - Vertical antennas can be enhanced by adding a sloper wire off the top of the antenna to give NVIS operation on lower bands and directional gain on upper bands. For SOTA, this simple addition offers extreme flexibility in portable operation. This study compares the relative gain of the Chameleon MPAS Lite system with a 17'vertical and a sloper wire.
Elevated vs Ground mounted Vertical Study - In this study the elevated POTA Performer antenna system is compared to the Chameleon MPAS Lite system. Elevated antennas and radials offer a significant efficinecy improvement over ground mounted system. This study will quantify that improvement in terms of relative gain. In addition the AI Gemini engine is used to also predict the antenna performance and the resukts compared to the WSPR study.
A Rybakov Vertical Antenna Study - This study compare the performance of a 25' vertical Rybakov style antenna system to the Chameleon MPAS Lite system using a 17' vertical. The Rybakov antenna is a multi-band non-resonant antenna that is easy to construct and deploy. It is also compact enough to take on SOTA activations. A WSPR study is used to predict the reative gain of the Rybakov system. A SOTA activation using the Rybkov is also discussed.